Skip Navigation

Nobel Laureates Defend E.U. Animal Research Rules Against Citizens' Proposal

Published in Science

More than 1 million citizens from 26 countries have formally urged the European Commission to scrap a 2010 directive that regulates the use of animals in scientific research. The Stop Vivisection European Citizens' Initiative (ECI), submitted to the Commission in March, calls for a “paradigm shift in the way biomedical and toxicological research are being conducted.” The proponents want the Commission to put forward a fresh proposal phasing out animal testing in favor of “more accurate, reliable, human-relevant methods.”

The Commission must now consider turning the proposal into legislation; it has until early June to respond.

In an open letter published yesterday in The Times and the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, the Nobel Prize winners call on the Commission to ignore the plea. They say the directive was “carefully considered,” and that repealing it would “represent a significant step backwards” both for animal welfare and for European research. “We do not wish for animals to be involved in research forever, and the research community is committed to finding alternative models. However, we are not there yet,” write the signatories.

The letter was issued just days before the Initiative's proponents speak at the European Parliament. One of the signatories, Françoise Barré-Sinoussi, will also speak at the public hearing in Brussels on Monday.

Stop Vivisection is the third ECI to reach this stage since this tool for direct democracy was introduced 3 years ago. The Commission has rejected the previous two (including last year's plea to stop using E.U. funding for stem cell research), much to the frustration of citizens' groups, which also complain that the procedures are restrictive and cumbersome. “The pressure [on the Commission to take action] is bigger compared to previous initiatives,” says Carsten Berg, coordinator of the ECI Campaign, a group that lobbies to reform the tool.

However, experts say the Commission is unlikely to scrap legislation adopted after lengthy negotiations, which would mean reverting back to rules from 1986. "Europe has been in the lead of replacing animal experiments for decades," and although its implementation could go further, the directive has been an important part of raising standards, says Thomas Hartung, director of the Johns Hopkins University Center for Alternatives to Animal Testing in Baltimore, Maryland. “A lot of this [discussion] is about enforcing the directive credibly, not just about getting rid of it,” he adds.

Even if it doesn't get the directive scrapped, says Hartung, the ECI has succeeded in prompting a conversation. “A large part of society wants us [scientists] to be extremely careful when using such precious resources,” he says. “Researchers cannot just handle this among themselves.” 

Full Article in Science

New ALTEX: 3/2017
ALTEX 3/2017 cover

Support ALTWEB, Make a Gift
Online Humane Science Course


FRAME Training School in Experimental Design and Statistical Analysis
May 31-June 2, 2017
Saskatoon, Canada

Advances in Cell and Tissue Culture 2017
May 22-24, 2017
Manchester, UK

CAAT Academy
In Vitro Skin and Eye Models Hands-on Training
June 1-2 2017
Brussels, Belgium

CAAT Academy
Tools for Read-Across
June 15-16, 2017
Helsinki, Finland

ecopa SSCT Workshop 2017
June 14-16, 2017
Helsinki, Finland
Thomas Hartung will deliver a keynote address

CAAT Academy
Updates on Hepatotoxicity AOP Landscape and on the ADME Field - Season 2
June 22-23, 2017
Rennes, France

9th Euro-Global Summit on Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology
June 22-24, 2017
Paris, France
Email for Details

6th Annual Meeting of the American Society for Cellular and Computational Toxicology (ASCCT)
September 21-22
College Park, MD

10th World Congress on Alternatives and Animal Use in the Life Sciences
August 20-24, 2017
Seattle, Washington

CAAT Academy
Hands-on Training in Quantitative Human Cell and Effect-based In Vitro Bioanalysis for Assessing Endocrine-disrupting Compounds (EDCs)
September 7-8. 2017

More Meetings...